Envision that you are a Human Services worker at the local Community Family Homeless shelter. You are preparing for the Holiday gift giving event by matching the donated gifts to your clients. You consider yourself to be an ethical professional. However, you are questioning whether it is ethical to switch the gift tag on one gift. One of the little girls at the shelter lost her favorite “American Girl” doll and has been crying about her lost doll since she and her family arrived at the shelter. Today, you see that a “American Girl” doll gift is tagged to another child at the shelter. What do you do?
Review the Codes of Ethics and Decision-Making Models Comparative Charts and Response that you completed for Week 2.
Week2 assignmentConcluding Case
Role of Human Services Professionals
The main function of human services professionals is to create an environment where clients can achieve self-determination regardless of the issues that they experience (Neukrug, 2016). In the case section, the human services professional is a high school counselor working with a student-athlete playing in the basketball team. For the counselor, the key expectation is that the student would be able to gain an in-depth understanding of crucial desires that prompt him to engage in underage drinking. Therefore, this creates a situation where the counselor seeks to advance the least intrusive intervention, which would ensure that the student is able to understand the factors promoting such behaviors.
On the other hand, the counselor must also consider creating the least restrictive environment for the student as a way of ensuring that indeed the student would achieve the expected results. In a least restrictive environment, a human services professional is expected to advance a position within which clients can change within a given period rather than having to pressure them to change. In this case, this may be seen from the position where the counselor ought to focus on creating an environment where the student can reflect on his actions individually. However, the decision to change must come from within the student and may occur within a given period without any pressures.
Ethical Dilemma
The ethical dilemma, which has been presented in this case is about the zero-tolerance policy for student-athletes engaging in illegal activities, which include underage drinking. One important aspect to note is that the student was self-referred, thus, meaning that the counselor is bound to the student regardless of the information gathered during the case. However, the counselor feels bound to share such information with the basketball coach considering that the school has a policy on illegal activities. The ethical dilemma arises from the fact that although the counselor may want to share information with the basketball coach, the counselor is also expected to consider the student in making that decision. The counselor must remember all ethical principle regarding the student while sharing such information.
How to Approach the Ethical Dilemma
Respecting Confidentiality
The counselor may deal with the ethical dilemma, as has been described, by respecting the confidentiality of information shared by the student. In this case, the client was self-referred meaning that the counselor was bound by a contract to help the student overcome the issue that he was facing. As a human service professional, the counselor is expected to respect the student’s confidentiality while ensuring that the information shared remains confidential. Thus, this means that the counselor will not be expected to share any information with the basketball coach, as this would go against respecting the student’s confidentiality.
Providing Informed Consent
Informed consent is one of the main elements associated with the human service profession. In this case, the counselor may seek to deal with the dilemma by providing the student with an informed consent indicating the duty for the counselor to share any information given with the basketball coach. The student will decide on whether he will sign the informed consent depending on whether he believes that the information ought to be shared with the coach. Informed consent gives the authority for counselors to share the information with the coach regarding the student. “Informed consent is a formal authorization that is used by allowing the student information to be transformed to the coach from the counselor’s for participation. Usually before a profession can even speak about a student to another source them must have a consent form must be signed. Informed consent is required in human service agencies. It is vital that the counselor and the student understand what the consent form consist of and that they make sure that all elements are present before obtaining consent.
To obtain consent these basic elements must be included. The counselor and the student must be informed about of the possible outcomes, alternatives, risks, and must understand that there is no certainty on outcome. The student must also understand why he is giving consent and should be able to repeat in his own words for which he is giving consent.
Duty to Warn and Duty to Protect
The counselor has a duty to warn, meaning that he is expected to share any information that he may deem as necessary with the basketball coach. The duty to warn creates a situation where the student ought to understand that one of the key roles of the counselor is to share information that may impact the institution. On the other hand, the duty to protect creates a situation where the counselor should protect the student by not sharing any information with the basketball coach
Even though the counselor has a duty to warn the counselor must abide by the ethical principal to do no harm, also if a client make cause harm to themselves then the counselor has a duty to warn because the student is in danger of harming himself.
Write a 400- to 550-word paper in which you discuss your ethical decision to switch the tag or not:
Include how you apply the ethical guidelines to make an informed ethical decision.
Identify your personal and professional values and attitudes regarding the ethical situation
Describe how you will ensure that you are engaged in an ethical human service practice
Format your paper consistent with APA guidelines.
Previous answers to this question
This is a preview of an assignment submitted on our website by a student. If you need help with this question or any assignment help, click on the order button below and get started. We guarantee authentic, quality, 100% plagiarism free work or your money back.
Get The Answer